Cultural Wedding Boards
Cat:Cultural Wedding Boards
Bigoted relatives
Jewish Weddings
Bigoted relatives
Planning a Jewish Wedding? Share your plans and inspiration here.
I regret that I didn't speak up yesterday when one of my uncles made a really offensive anti-Semitic comment at the party after my niece's baptism. The man is an across the board bigot and has said so
0
False
Jewish Weddings
Bigoted relatives
Planning a Jewish Wedding? Share your plans and inspiration here.
I regret that I didn't speak up yesterday when one of my uncles made a really offensive anti-Semitic comment at the party after my niece's baptism. The man is an across the board bigot and has said so
0
Cat:Cultural Wedding BoardsForum:399
Cat:Cultural Wedding BoardsForum:399Discussion:10487893
Forums  >  Cultural Wedding Boards  >  Jewish Weddings  >  Bigoted relatives
You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 

Bigoted relatives

posted at 11/9/2009 8:26 AM EST
Joined on
11-16-2007
PHOENIX
4198307961143750
Posts: 2485
First: 7/23/2009

Last: 5/6/2012


I regret that I didn't speak up yesterday when one of my uncles made a really offensive anti-Semitic comment at the party after my niece's baptism. The man is an across the board bigot and has said some awful things not only about Jews (although he has never known any except for my husband and now me), African Americans, gays, Asians, Hispanics or basically anyone who is not exactly like him. There's nothing uglier than a drunken racist / bigot.

I rationalized that my silence was not approval but that i did not want to cause an ugly scene and take away from the celebration.

I find it ironic hat to some more traditional people I'm not even considered Jewish because I studied with a female Reform rabbi and had a Reform conversion but to some family members I'm "the Jew" and that's not really a positive thing.
TTC since 3-08 Diagnosed with severe MFI 2-09 and Y Chromosome Microdeletion. IVF #1, Nov-Dec '11. ER Dec 3, 5dt, Dec 8. Beta #1, 218, Beta #2, 599. EDD 8/25/12 [IMG]http://i33.tinypic.com/1enzn6.jpg[/IMG] Daisypath Anniversary tickers Photobucket

Bigoted relatives

posted at 11/9/2009 8:33 AM EST
Joined on
07-08-2006
SANTA BARBARA/VENTURA
225935437503108
Posts: 218
First: 7/28/2009

Last: 3/21/2012


Just look at him and say: You know uncle XXXX.... thank god bigotry isn't genetic or I could have ended up like you...and walk away.

Adam & Shoshie 10-21-07: "My family is big and loud and everybody's in each other's lives and business. ... but wherever I go, they will always be there." * My Blog: Tales of a Jewish Suburbanite * Anniversary

Bigoted relatives

posted at 11/9/2009 9:55 AM EST
Joined on
01-03-2009
BOSTON
4377666019207249
Posts: 3607
First: 7/20/2009

Last: 10/2/2011


I'm sorry :(
I think I'd react like you... I wouldn't want to cause a scene but inside I'd boiling. I just don't undstand people sometimes...

Bigoted relatives

posted at 11/10/2009 4:28 AM EST
Joined on
03-04-2009
OUTER BOROUGHS
6344717764601518
Posts: 1151
First: 7/10/2009

Last: 9/29/2010


It's a tough position to be in.  Had it just been a regular dinner or get together, I would have unleased.  But you are right, it was your niece's baptism and if saying something would have caused a scene, despite the fact that you would be right, many might have been upset that you couldn't let it go for the sake of the event.
Everything is about timing; what I may have done, had I been in your shoes, is say something to him as the festivities were winding down.  But it can't just be you; if other family members don't say anything and he continues to be invited to functions, then he doesn't have to change his ways.
I would never allow a family member, whether on my side or his, to attend any function I was holding.  If someone else had a function and he was going to be there, I'd make it clear to not seat us anywhere near the person.  The more you voice your dislike for a person's actions, others will pick up and follow suit.

Re: Bigoted relatives

posted at 11/18/2009 10:48 AM EST on theknot.com
Joined on
04-27-2008
PHILADELPHIA
7864448901171406
Posts: 267
First: 7/24/2009

Last: 7/29/2010


I think you did the right thing by not taking the attention away from your niece's celebration, but I would approach him privately on a different occasion (or perhaps, contact him) and tell him that his commentary was unnecessary, inappropriate, bigoted and unappreciated.  Obviously, you can't change him being a bigot, but you can make it clear that you won't tolerate him spouting hateful remarks around you and your DH any longer.  If he can't keep his mouth shut, he could at least, zip it around you.

My Viewing Preferences

Show user signatures

about our featured blogger

We're so thrilled to announce Eyal Tessler, of In Any Event event planning, as our Jewish wedding blogger. Event planning is Eyal Tessler’s strongest passion. Originally from Israel, Eyal obtained his bachelor degree from Tel Aviv University in Mass Communication and Business Administration. Over 15 years, experience in diverse markets such as Israel and New York have contributed to his imaginative approach to design, high sensitivity, and understanding of all needs, wants and budgets.

planning an interfaith wedding?

Get tips and advice for wedding that combines cultures:

Special thanks to Nina Sacks, Danny Weiss, Brunk Photography and Lisa Lefkowitz Photography for our featured Jewish wedding photos

Local Wedding Vendors, Local Wedding Cake Makers, Local Wedding Florists, Local Wedding Photographers, Local Real Weddings